Academic Rigour Denounced

Dr Gorg Mifsud Chircop is the leading academic folklorist in Malta. He has written dozens of worthy pieces on the folklore of that island, and is the organiser of an annual conference on behalf of the International Society for Ethnology and Folklore. So one might assume that his bona fides are pretty solid.

So imagine his horror and amazement when he was forced to apologise for a number of ancient Maltese proverbs which he was discussing in an academic seminar.

He was using the proverbs to illustrate his point that the Catholic Maltese use the word “Alla” to define God, after hundreds of years of Muslim influence on Malta. He was trying to explain the contradictions and confusions and Islamophobia inherent on the island since the Great Siege of Malta (1565), when 592 Knights Hospitaller and a couple of thousand Maltese militia defeated an Ottoman force of 30,000.

When he got to this point in the paper where he was reading, “Alla hanin, Muhammed hanzir” (God is merciful, Mohammed is a pig) about 20 North African academics started shouting at him that he was abusing the prophet. Some stormed out. As Dr Chircop said “I honestly didn’t expect them, as academics, to be so sensitive, It’s a pity because it means that even at an academic level, there cannot be a free and objective analysis.”

Dr Chircop was forced to apologise and the University of Malta censored the reports of the seminar to remove all references to the proverb.

What makes this story interesting is that it took place, not in the fevered atmosphere of the post cartoon debate, not even in the post 9/11 world, but six years ago.

craven dhimmitude

The most interesting part of the whole affair is that your source was the only organisation to report this up till now - the rest of the Maltese media - both electronic and print, have drawn a curtain over it.

This just goes to show the power of the internet - I wouldn't have found out about it if it were not for the Brussels Journal - and it happened in my own country. The media is really short changing us!

This is worth a note on our blog - Thanks Brussels Journal!

A Crime Against History

Ridiculous, and as usual profoundly illiberal. Malta’s role as a crossroads of cultures is something to celebrate, even by those who denigrate its role in the defense of the West. Malta’s unique linguistic heritage must be understood, and is profoundly illuminating and hopeful as it showcases the potential for cultures to change while retaining old elements. And the outcry shows how far beyond the pale the Islamist agenda can reach – if a neutral discussion of history must be rejected, what place does academia have?
An Arab Chronicler wrote that when the Muslim armies conquered Egypt, their commander wrote to the Caliph asking what to do with the library of Alexandria, which was disused and damaged but not destroyed. The Caliph responded that if what was in the books was true it was in the Koran, and hence redundant, and should be burned, while if the contents were against the Koran they were false and should be burned – so he ordered the library to be burned either way. The Muslims latter moderated and came to respect learning – and now seem to have forgotten it again.

http://www.slouchingtosarajevo.blogspot.com/

Madness

Believer, you are mad in the most vivacious way. Amusing. Interesting. Well read. Mad.You are such an interesting hater.

rpmcestmoi RE: HATE

new believer represents MOST non muslims. she definitely had the backing of the majority of filipino catholics or non muslims. and the entire non muslim world. it's perfectly healthy to HATE all muslims or islam! it's good for the soul...mmm sharia law in afghanistan, recent news, they threaten to kill a guy for converting to christianity.
what kind of religion advoctates MURDERING someone who decides to change belief?
do you see any other belief system that FORCES death for someone who simply want to get out of a religion, there goes your religion of peace. the world will eventually get sick, or at least the powerful nations of muslims and exterminate them from the earth. we in the west call it
CRUSADE!

Re Madness.. Moi! hien!

Actually, I was not always so quaint in my little
eccentricities...
one could say I started out as an
"equal opportunity hater".

It is true I hated EVERYONE regardless
of race, creed, colour or place of national origin!

Then a strange, but most certainly odd occurrence
happened mon ami!
The little grey cells began to awaken, to blossom as it were.. and so
I made exceptions to my petite hatreds. I opened my borders, stamped visas..let people inside. Gathered around me diverse and interesting souls.
(A most delightful Scandinavian has captured my heart
now! This comes later.. I digress!)

Then before you know it a most incompatible creatures emerged!
"muslims" Oh!
Incroyable! Eh bien! They crept and slimed their way inside my defenses, Before you could say.."Laissez Bon Temp Roulez" They were inside. It was..a travesty..a tragedy! I was overrun. The carnage, the blasphemies, the digusting camel dung..it permeates everything..hien!

I escaped..... fortunately for me!
My course was clear, the way was set. I had to tell the world about them! Ca Ira! But I know deep in my heart of hearts.. De Gaulle would understand!

Odin be Praised!  Baldur Save Us!

to new believer

SO DOES STICKING TWO GERBILS IN ONE ASS(DONKEY)monkey!
isn't standard operating procedure according to muslim tradition? I learned that from kungfumaster who told me that he learned that from master gerbil kung fu master who was taught by the great yoda who likes to drink pepsi cola as his soda.

where did GODZILLA go anyway? he might want to eat some muslim tortillas by frying a couple of mooselimbs in malta!

Malta and islam

Hi there. I am a Maltese citizen, and I am one of the growing number who are realising that we, as Maltese, are being betrayed by a government who never fails to rise to the occasion to kowtow to the sacred cow of political correctness or to grovel abjectly at the first word uttered his masters at Brussels, all the while, accepting ever growing numbers of illegal immigrants with no regard to our security, and indeed with no regard to how our tiny country will be able to support such an influx.

500 years ago my forefathers saved Europe from the islamic invasion of the Ottoman Empire. Today the traitors in government are making my country a bus stop for illegal immigrants - a springboard from where any African can leap into the European heartland. Increasingly people who speak out against this suicidal policy are being silenced, denigrated and defamed.

This year it appears likely that due to a change in European legislation, Malta will be responsible for rescuing and hosting all illegal immigrants found throughout most of the Mediterranean, from Tunisia to Crete. Such an unprecedented influx will no doubt massively overload our detention centres, forcing all immigrants to be let out unchecked, whether they qualify for refugee status or not, no matter their possible criminal background, no matter what contagious diseases they might carry. Malta is a small overcrowded island with a population of 400,000. The health problems alone this invasion is liable to cause will be unprecedented in this country since the medieval plague and our health services are not equipped to cope!
It appears after all that Frattini's call for Malta to become a "mega-detention centre" will be foisted on us whether we want it or not. Our country is being slowly stolen from us, but if I know my countrymen, no Maltese will let this happen without a fight. 500 years ago our forefathers saved Europe. Perhaps it is about time we follwed in their footsteps.

I believe in the freedom of

I believe in the freedom of speech. Actually I believe in an unlimited freedom of speech: The freedom of speech is at the core of every living democracy. Once we start limiting it, we are in serious troubles.

These 'angry Muslims' however only reckon with the fact that there are restricting laws, they do not look into the judicial impact of these restrictions - the impact being that it is, once again, very difficult to convict someone based on such restrictions - the impact is almost none. Especially in the last couple of years / decade(s). We are even talking about changing our Constitution(s) to broaden the freedom of speech. Although restrictions exist, the Western culture is one of great tolerance. Lets just say the Arab world is not famous for íts level of tolerance towards those who disagree with the majority opinion - This "Malta Story" shows that

RE: FREEDOM OF SPEECH

I guarantee muslims will NEVER, EVER BE ABLE TO RESTRICT ANYONE FROM FREEDOM OF SPEECH cause this is the WESTERN DEMOCRACY THAT HAS HISTORY OF CIVIL WARS when they don't agree with government and religion.
There are so many races and religions here and non religion, it is impossible for MUSLIMS to try to get things done there way like they do in some parts of europe.
People here will take matters into their own hands if it's get out of hand. That is what so pathetic about president bush and his cronies in politics, business and the media who wholeheartedly go out of their way to BEND THEIR KNEES TOWARDS ARABS AND MUSLIMS...the AMERICAN people no better. They can make as many speeches as they want in their defense of muslims or so called peaceful muslims, but many of us will RESIST them with all of our mights. Most americans do not accept ISLAM period. More people are being educated as to how dangerous this religion is. It makes me laugh when I hear all these muslim and muslim supporters say it's the fastest growing religion. what a bold face lie. They are basically saying, people are in a hurry to be SLAVES! I DON'T THINK SO, CERTAINLY NOT HERE IN THE U.S. which people like to cherish FOUL LANGUAGE!

Stop apologizing

This is why followers of Islam, is the greatest threat to democracies everywhere, every time any issues comes into conflict with their beliefs they go absolutely nuts and demand apologies and things to change so they conform with Islam, even in non Islamic countries, and there is absolutely no reasoning with them, if their demands are not met they will declare jihad, no matter how scientific, historic, humorous, innocent etc. the issue might be to the rest of the world.

“Dr Chircop was forced to apologise and the University of Malta censored the reports of the seminar to remove all references to the proverb.”

As long as the Muslims get politicians, news agencies, educational institutions etc. etc. to cave in to their demands, they will keep up this despicable behaviour until Islam is the religion of the world. The only way out is to tell them that, no way, no how will we in free democratic countries let Islam rule our way of life, and if they don’t like that they are extremely welcome to stay clear of our countries.

fear as consumer product /pretense and a product of deception

Oh! The drama!

it isn't just that Islamics have a sensitive heart to supposed blasphemy against what really doesn't exist and should get over it; it is also that they have perceived that they can pretend to be offended by anything and silence many by theatrics. Those that are silenced by the theatrics admit publically they have been cowards in secret all their lives and that what is plainly theatrics and manipulation is and has been their perception of reality all along.

They are all, both the deceivers and deceived almost as obvious as 'professional' wrestlers writhing in supposed pain to get a reaction from the audience at the supposed cruelty of their opponent. Some people in the audience really think a true fist fight is on-going and somebody ain't fightin' fair.

Psalm 49:13 This their way is their folly, yet they that come after them delight in their sayings. Selah.

In the Name of Jesus Christ, Amen